Business Valuation in Divorce: Section 25 Explained

16 min read By

How a business is valued on divorce under Section 25 MCA 1973, which methods and standards apply, and how to spot an undervalued business or hidden assets.

A court does not apply a formula to a business in divorce. Section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 tells it to weigh all the circumstances, including each spouse's financial resources, so the business value is evidence in a wider fairness exercise. It matters most where the business must be sold, shared or offset against other assets.

Last updated: 17 November 2026

How does the court value a business in divorce under Section 25?

The court treats the business as one of the spouses' financial resources under section 25(2)(a) and reaches a fair outcome on all the circumstances. It does not need a single "correct" number. It needs a reliable range, an understanding of how liquid the business is, and evidence of what it earns.

Section 25(1) makes the welfare of any child of the family under 18 the first consideration. Section 25(2) then lists the matters the court must have regard to. Several of them bear directly on a business:

  • Section 25(2)(a): income, earning capacity, property and other financial resources each party has or is likely to have in the foreseeable future. This is where the company, partnership interest or sole trader business sits, together with the income it produces.
  • Section 25(2)(b): financial needs, obligations and responsibilities. A business that cannot be sold or drained without harming the family's income changes what each side actually needs.
  • Section 25(2)(f): contributions to the welfare of the family, including looking after the home and caring for the family. A spouse who did not work in the business can still have contributed.
  • Section 25(2)(g): conduct, but only where it would be inequitable to disregard it.

The other factors, standard of living, age and length of the marriage, disability and benefits lost on divorce, still apply. The House of Lords in White v White [2000] UKHL 54 treated equal division as a yardstick against which a proposed outcome is checked, to be departed from only for good reason, and said there is no place for discrimination between the respective roles of husband and wife. Parties may also argue about whether some or all of the business is matrimonial or non-matrimonial property, and that argument can change how much the headline value matters.

So the valuation is evidence, not the answer. A well-supported figure lets the parties and the judge decide whether the business is shared through a lump sum, offset against the home or pension, paid out over time, or left with the owner while the other spouse is compensated elsewhere. A weak figure distorts every one of those choices. The next section covers where weak figures usually come from.

What We See in Practice: where do undervaluations come from?

Undervaluation in divorce rarely comes from one dramatic act. It comes from ordinary accounting judgements that each look defensible alone but all move the same way. A forensic accountant reads the accounts for the direction of travel, not just the closing profit.

This section describes the method and the patterns practitioners recognise. It is general, and it is not a description of any particular case.

The accounts are written for HMRC, not for a valuation

Statutory accounts and tax computations are prepared to report tax, not to show what an owner could sustainably take out of the business. Owner-managed companies often run personal costs through the business: vehicles, travel, family members on the payroll, home-office or property costs. Some are legitimate business costs. Some are lifestyle. A valuation works from maintainable earnings, so each item has to be examined and either accepted or added back.

Remuneration moves in the years that matter

Directors choose between salary, dividends, pension contributions and loan account movements. A salary that rises sharply in the year or two before separation lowers profit and, with a capitalised multiple, can reduce the value by several times the extra pay. The reverse also happens: a below-market salary can make a business look more profitable than it is, which matters if the other side is arguing the business is worth less. Both directions need a market rate for the role as the benchmark.

Choosing the trading period

Earnings from one weak year, a pandemic-affected year or a year with a one-off cost can be presented as the new normal. Equally, a single exceptional year can be extrapolated. A sound analysis looks at several years, adjusts for one-offs, and explains why the period chosen is representative.

Related-party dealings and the balance sheet

Sales and purchases with connected companies, management charges, intercompany balances and rent paid to a property held personally or by a family member can all move profit between entities. On the balance sheet, a director's loan account, accruals, provisions and stock or work-in-progress valuations deserve a second look, because they affect both earnings and net assets.

Value that is not in the accounts

Some value never reaches the balance sheet: customer contracts, intellectual property, a pipeline of work, or a subsidiary that is not consolidated. Equally, a figure given in Form E may rest on a short letter from the family's own accountant. Form E asks for business accounts and any documents used to estimate value, so the basis for the figure should be visible. If it is only a number with no workings, the workings have to be asked for.

The common thread is that none of these needs fabricated documents. They need someone to look closely at documents that already exist, and to ask the right follow-up questions through the court process.

Which valuation method suits which business?

The method follows the business. Profitable trading companies are usually valued on maintainable earnings, businesses with uncertain growth on discounted cash flow, and asset-heavy or property companies on net assets. Practitioners normally cross-check at least two methods rather than rely on one multiple.

The table sets out how each method works and where it tends to go wrong.

  • Maintainable earnings (capitalisation). Normalise profit, then apply a multiple reflecting risk and growth. Fits established, profitable trading businesses. The multiple is a judgement, and a small change moves the value a long way.
  • Discounted cash flow. Forecast future cash flows and discount them to today at a rate reflecting risk. Fits growth businesses and uneven earnings. Forecasts drift towards what the instructing party wants, and the discount rate is easy to challenge.
  • Net asset value. Adjust the balance sheet to realistic values and deduct liabilities. Fits property and investment companies, holding structures and loss-making businesses. It ignores goodwill, and book values may not reflect market values.
  • Market comparables. Compare with sales of similar businesses. Fits sectors with enough reliable transaction data. Small private companies seldom match the data that is available.

Two issues cut across all four. The first is what is being valued: the whole company, a minority holding, or one spouse's share of a partnership. The second is personal goodwill. If customers follow the owner rather than the business, much of the earnings may be the owner's own effort, which is already being treated as income. Counting it again as capital is the double counting argument that comes up when the owner will keep and run the business.

Where there is a dispute about the multiple or the discount rate, the useful question is what evidence supports it. A range with stated assumptions is more honest, and more useful to a court, than a single figure that conceals them.

Which standard of value applies, and why does it matter?

The standard of value is the question the valuer is answering. Market value asks what a willing buyer would pay a willing seller. Other bases, such as value to an owner who keeps the business, can give different figures. The expert should state which one they use, and the instruction should say.

The difference is practical. A market value on a hypothetical sale may apply discounts for lack of marketability or for a minority holding. If the business is going to stay with the owner, and the other spouse is being paid out of other assets, it is arguable that those discounts do not reflect reality. If the business will in fact be sold, they may. Which basis fits is part of the argument, not a technical detail to be left to the expert alone.

Two further points are worth fixing in the letter of instruction:

  • The valuation date. A business can change materially between the date of the accounts, the date of Form E and the hearing. State the date and ask for updates if the gap grows.
  • Whether tax on a sale is deducted. Whether to allow for tax on a hypothetical sale, and how much, is contested. It should be stated openly, with the figure shown both before and after the adjustment.

If the instructions do not settle these points, two experts, or two readers of one report, can each be right on their own assumptions and still be a long way apart. A clear basis, set out at the start, narrows the argument to the facts.

How do you spot hidden assets or an undervalued business?

You look for inconsistencies between records that should agree. Spending that outstrips declared income, profit that does not match bank receipts, or a lifestyle at odds with the accounts are the usual starting points. None of them proves concealment, but each justifies a targeted request for documents.

The cross-checks a forensic accountant typically runs include:

  1. Compare turnover in the accounts with VAT returns and with the credits on the business bank statements.
  2. Compare declared personal income with personal bank statements, credit card statements and the spending pattern over several years.
  3. Trace large or unexplained payments out of the business, including to connected parties, and any loan balances that appear or disappear.
  4. Review cash-heavy trades for takings that look low for the premises, staffing or stock purchases.
  5. Check the public record: Companies House filings, confirmation statements, persons with significant control, charges and recent changes of directors or shareholders.
  6. Look for assets held through other vehicles: a second company, a trust, a family member's name, or an overseas account.
  7. Compare accounts and documents prepared for lenders, insurers or buyers with the figures put forward in the divorce.

Be careful about how this evidence is obtained. Disclosure should come through the court process: questionnaires, requests for specific documents and, where justified, applications for orders. Looking at a spouse's private emails or accounts without permission can create legal problems of its own, so solicitors should advise before any document is used.

For the wider process of following assets through a case, see our guide on tracing hidden assets in divorce proceedings and the asset tracing service.

Who should value the business: a joint expert or a party expert?

Usually a single joint expert, because the court controls expert evidence in financial remedy proceedings and favours one report on one set of instructions. A party can rely on expert evidence only with the court's permission, and permission is limited to what is necessary to resolve the case.

Part 25 of the Family Procedure Rules 2010 governs this. Rule 25.4 prevents expert evidence being put before the court without permission and allows permission only where the evidence is necessary to assist the court to resolve the proceedings. Rule 25.3 makes the expert's duty to the court override any duty to the person who instructs or pays them. Under rule 25.11 the court may direct a single joint expert where two or more parties want expert evidence on the same issue, and instructions are normally given in a jointly agreed letter under rule 25.12. The content of the report is governed by Practice Direction 25B.

A joint expert is not always the whole answer for the party with the weaker position. A party-appointed expert, if the court gives permission, or an adviser working outside the proceedings, can be useful for a shadow review: testing the joint expert's assumptions, framing the written questions, or advising on whether the joint report should be challenged. The trade-offs are set out in our guide to single joint expert vs party-appointed forensic accountant, and the expert's duties are covered in the forensic accountant as expert witness.

Whichever route is used, the quality of the letter of instruction decides most of what follows. It should name the valuation date, the standard of value, the documents to be reviewed, the issues in dispute, and the questions the expert is to answer. A vague letter produces a vague report, and a late letter leaves no time to fix it.

Our forensic accountant for divorce and matrimonial finance pages explain the roles we take in these cases.

What if the business was undervalued or concealed after the order?

A financial order can be set aside where it was obtained on the basis of fraudulent or deliberately incomplete disclosure, but the bar is high and the process is expensive. The Supreme Court considered this in Sharland v Sharland [2015] UKSC 60 and the linked case of Gohil v Gohil [2015] UKSC 61.

In Sharland, where the husband's fraud was material to the court's decision, the Supreme Court held that the order should be set aside, and that it was for the party who had deceived to show that the order would not have been significantly different. In Gohil, the Supreme Court held that the Ladd v Marshall fresh-evidence principles have no relevance to an application to set aside a financial order for non-disclosure, and it reinstated the judge's order setting aside the earlier consent order. These decisions protect a spouse who was misled, but they are not a substitute for scrutiny during the proceedings. A challenge after the event means new litigation, a hearing on what was withheld, and an uncertain outcome, and it relies on evidence that may have been easier to obtain earlier.

The practical point for solicitors is timing. The opportunity to test a business valuation is before the consent order is approved. If doubts exist about the valuation, they should be raised and addressed before then, by asking for more disclosure, instructing an expert, or recording the basis on which the order is agreed.

Frequently asked questions

Is a business always valued in a divorce?

No. If the business is small, the accounts are simple and both sides accept a figure or a range, the court may not need a formal valuation. The court gives permission for expert evidence only where it is necessary to resolve the case, so a formal valuation is an application, not an automatic step.

Can my spouse's accountant value the business?

They can give a view, and it may appear in Form E. But an accountant who acts for the business or its owner is not independent. An expert instructed in the proceedings owes a duty to the court under rule 25.3 of the Family Procedure Rules 2010, and that duty overrides any obligation to the person who instructs or pays them.

Does the valuation date matter?

Yes, because a business can change between the last accounts, Form E and the hearing. The instruction should state the date to be used, and the expert should say what has changed since then. A figure that is stale by the time of the hearing is easier to challenge.

Can the court order the business to be sold?

Section 24A of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 allows the court, when it makes a lump sum or property adjustment order, to order the sale of property in which either spouse has a beneficial interest. Whether a sale is appropriate for a business is a separate question, and in general the court can consider solutions that avoid damaging the business or the income that supports both households, such as an offset against other assets or payment over time. What is realistic depends on the business and on what the valuation shows about liquidity.

What is the difference between a business valuer and a forensic accountant?

A valuer estimates what the business is worth on a stated basis. A forensic accountant can do that too, and also investigates whether the underlying records are reliable: reconciling accounts to bank statements, adjusting earnings, and tracing funds. Where the figures themselves are in doubt, that investigation usually has to come first.

What documents are usually needed for a business valuation in divorce?

Typically statutory accounts and tax computations for several years, management accounts, business bank statements, VAT returns, the company's filings, the directors' loan account, and details of any related-party dealings. Form E asks for the business accounts for the last two financial years and any documents the estimate of value is based on, but a sound valuation normally needs more than that.

Conclusion

In a divorce, a business is valued as one of the financial resources under section 25(2)(a) of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, and the number is only part of a wider fairness exercise. The method should fit the business, the standard of value and valuation date should be fixed in the instructions, and a single joint expert is the usual route under Part 25 of the Family Procedure Rules. Undervaluation usually comes from ordinary accounting choices, so the accounts should be cross-checked against bank, VAT and Companies House records before any consent order is agreed.

If you are a family solicitor or a business owner facing a contested valuation or suspected non-disclosure, contact Key Ledgers to discuss the instruction before the valuation basis is agreed, while the questions are still open.

Written by Bharat Varsani FCCA. Bharat is a Chartered Certified Accountant and CPR Part 35-qualified expert witness with extensive experience in matrimonial finance proceedings, including asset tracing, business valuation and non-disclosure investigations across the family courts of England and Wales.

Sources:Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, section 25; Family Procedure Rules 2010, Part 25; Practice Direction 25B; Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, section 24A; Form E financial statement (GOV.UK); White v White [2000] UKHL 54; Sharland v Sharland [2015] UKSC 60; Gohil v Gohil [2015] UKSC 61.

Need a forensic accountant? Let's talk.

Send an Enquiry